Mechanical Trading Vs. Discretionary Trading: Pros & Cons

There are two main types of trading strategies: mechanical and discretionary. Mechanical trading strategies are based on a set of pre-defined rules that are applied consistently to the market. Discretionary trading strategies, on the other hand, rely on the trader’s judgment and experience to make trading decisions.

Each type of trading has its pros and cons. Mechanical trading can help to remove emotion from the trading process, but it can also be inflexible and may not adapt well to changing market scenarios. Discretionary trading can be more adaptable, but they can also be more prone to emotional bias. 

Many traders associated with funded trading programs in India strategize accordingly and then only enter their trades. This is because these programs typically have strict rules and risk management guidelines that traders must follow. 

What is Mechanical Trading?

Mechanical trading strategies are rules-based and rely on predefined criteria and algorithms to make trading decisions. These rules can be programmed into computer systems, known as trading algorithms or trading robots, to automate the trading process. Mechanical trading strategies are designed to remove human emotions and biases from trading, as they execute trades solely based on objective criteria. 

For example, mechanical trading might have the following rules:

  • Buy when the price crosses above a moving average
  • Sell when the price crosses below a moving average
  • Close all trades at the end of the day

Mechanical trading strategies can be implemented manually or using automated trading software. 

Pros of Mechanical Trading

Mechanical trading has several advantages over discretionary trading. First, this trading style can help to remove emotion from the trading process. This is important because emotions can lead to bad trading decisions.

Second, mechanical trading strategies can be more disciplined than discretionary trading strategies. This is because these trading strategies are based on a set of pre-defined rules.

Cons of Mechanical Trading

Mechanical trading also has some disadvantages. First, these strategies can be inflexible. This is because they are based on a set of pre-defined rules that must be followed consistently. This can make it difficult for them to adapt to changing market conditions.

Second, mechanical trading strategies can be susceptible to overfitting. This is when a trading strategy is optimized to historical data and then fails to perform well in the live market.

What is Discretionary Trading?

Discretionary trading strategies, on the other hand, involve human judgment and decision-making in the trading process. Traders using discretionary trading style rely on their experience, analysis, and intuition to make trading decisions. These strategies can be highly adaptable and flexible, as they are not bound by rigid rules.

For example, a discretionary trader might buy a stock because they believe that the company’s earnings are going to increase in the future. Or, a discretionary trader might sell a stock because they believe that the market is going to crash.

Discretionary trading is more difficult than mechanical one because it requires traders to have a deep understanding of the markets and to be able to make sound trading decisions under pressure.

Pros of Discretionary Trading

Discretionary trading has several advantages over mechanical trading. First, it can be more adaptable because traders can use their judgment to adjust their trading strategies as per the market conditions.

Second, traders can take advantage of unique trading opportunities that would not be available to mechanical traders. For example, a trader might be able to buy a stock before it releases a positive earnings report.

Third, discretionary trading can be more rewarding than mechanical trading. This is because traders have the potential to make large profits from their trades.

Cons of Discretionary Trading

Discretionary trading also has some disadvantages. First, this trading strategy is more difficult than mechanical trading. Traders must have a deep understanding of the markets and be able to make sound trading decisions under pressure.

Second, traders are more susceptible to emotional bias. This is mainly because traders are making trading decisions based on their judgment and experience.

Which Type of Trading Strategy is Right for You?

It all depends on your individual personality and trading style. If you are disciplined and can stick to a set of rules, then mechanical trading may be a good option for you. If you are adaptable and able to make sound trading decisions under pressure, then discretionary trading may be a better option for you. Get funded today through Bespoke Funding Program and start your funded trading today.

Here is a table that summarizes the key differences between mechanical trading and discretionary trading:

CharacteristicMechanical TradingDiscretionary Trading
Rule-basedYesNo
AdaptableNoYes
Emotional biasLowHigh

Mechanical trading and discretionary trading strategies each have their strengths and weaknesses. The choice between them depends on the individual trader’s preferences, skills, and the specific state of the market they are dealing with. It’s crucial for traders to carefully assess their goals and risk tolerance and continually refine their strategies based on their experiences in the dynamic world of forex trading. 

Ultimately, the key to successful trading lies in disciplined risk management, ongoing learning, and the ability to adapt to ever-changing market situations, regardless of the chosen trading strategy.

Best Funded Trader Programs in India

At Bespoke Funding Program (BFP), we’re not just another trading entity – we’re one of the best prop trading firms that opens doors to a world of possibilities. 

Whether you’re starting small or aiming high, we have challenges that range from $25,000 to an impressive $500,000, with a cap of $4,000,000 per trader. Our team has meticulously crafted these challenges with a user-centric approach, ensuring they’re customized to cater to both beginners and experienced professionals.

(Note: This blog has been crafted based on the provided persona and scenario, and the information presented is for educational purposes only. Always conduct thorough research and seek professional advice before making any trading decisions.)

Join Our Discord Community

Stay up to date with everything BFP and network with our fantastic community of traders!

Challenge Type

  • Traders Choice
  • Standard Challenge

Account Size

  • $10,000
  • $25,000
  • $50,000
  • $100,000
  • $200,000
  • $300,000
  • $400,000

Account Type

Trading Platform